Does It Break My Fast?
Type a food, drink or supplement. You'll see whether it breaks a fast for your goal: weight loss, insulin and blood sugar, or a strict water-only fast.
- Doesn’t break itApple cider vinegarNo. A tablespoon of apple cider vinegar in water has about 3 calories and almost no sugar.
- DependsBCAAsYes, for insulin and strict fasts. BCAAs are amino acids, with about 20 to 40 calories a serving.
- Doesn’t break itBlack coffeeNo. Plain black coffee has about 2 calories a cup, too few to matter for weight loss or insulin.
- Breaks itBone brothYes. A cup of bone broth has about 30 to 50 calories and 6 to 10 grams of protein.
- Doesn’t break itChewing gumUsually not. A piece of sugar-free gum has about 2 to 5 calories. Gum with sugar has about 10.
- DependsCoffee with milkIt depends. A small splash is about 5 to 10 calories. A latte is a small meal and breaks a fast.
- Breaks itCollagenYes. Collagen is protein. A 10 gram scoop has about 35 to 40 calories and 9 grams of protein.
- Doesn’t break itCreatineNo. Plain creatine monohydrate has no calories and no sugar. Gummies and flavored mixes can differ.
- Doesn’t break itDiet sodaIt depends. Diet soda has no calories, so it won't stop weight loss. Its effect on insulin is unclear.
- Doesn’t break itElectrolytesNo, if they are unsweetened. Salt, potassium and magnesium have no calories. Sports drinks have sugar.
- Breaks itKombuchaYes. Regular kombucha has about 30 to 60 calories and 6 to 12 grams of sugar per 240 ml glass.
- Doesn’t break itLemon waterNo. A squeeze or a slice of lemon in water adds about 1 to 3 calories, too few to matter.
- Breaks itMCT oilYes. A tablespoon of MCT oil has about 100 to 130 calories of fat, even with no sugar or protein.
- Doesn’t break itMultivitaminNo. A multivitamin tablet has almost no calories. But most work better, and sit better, with food.
- Breaks itProtein shakeYes. A protein shake has about 100 to 200 calories and 20 to 30 grams of protein. It is a meal.
- Doesn’t break itSparkling waterNo. Plain sparkling water is water with bubbles: no calories, no sugar, no sweeteners.
- Doesn’t break itSteviaUsually not. Pure stevia has no calories. Its effect on insulin and appetite is not settled.
- Doesn’t break itSucraloseUsually not. Sucralose has no calories, but research on sweeteners and insulin is mixed.
- Doesn’t break itTeaNo. Plain tea has about 2 calories a cup. Milk, sugar or honey are what break a fast.
- Doesn’t break itToothpasteNo. You spit toothpaste out, so brushing your teeth adds no calories and doesn't break a fast.
We don't have a page for that yet. A simple rule: if it has calories, sugar or protein, it breaks a strict fast. A few calories (under about 10 to 15) won't make much difference to a fast for weight loss.
How to read the answers
Whether something "breaks" a fast depends on why you're fasting. Each item gets three answers:
- Weight loss. Does it add enough calories to matter? Weight change mostly comes down to calories in and out over time1, so a splash of milk is not the same as a latte.
- Blood sugar and insulin. Does it contain sugar, protein or enough calories to raise insulin? Low insulin is part of the switch from burning sugar to burning fat2.
- Strict fast. For a water-only fast or a gut rest, anything other than water counts. Black coffee and plain tea are a gray area, so they get "depends".
See every item on the does it break a fast page, or read what to drink while fasting.
Medicine is different. If you take prescription medicine, follow your doctor's or pharmacist's advice about taking it with food, even during a fast.
Questions people ask
How many calories break a fast?
There is no exact cut-off. For weight loss, a few calories, such as a splash of milk in coffee, make little difference. For a strict water-only fast, anything other than water counts, and black coffee or plain tea is a gray area.
Do zero-calorie sweeteners break a fast?
They add no calories, so they don’t stop a fast done for weight loss. Research on whether they affect insulin or appetite is mixed, so if your goal is blood sugar, plain drinks are the safer choice.
Sources
- Hall KD, Guo J (2017). Obesity Energetics: Body Weight Regulation and the Effects of Diet Composition. Gastroenterology.
- de Cabo R, Mattson MP (2019). Effects of Intermittent Fasting on Health, Aging, and Disease. N Engl J Med.