Alternate-day fasting: how it works and what studies found
Alternate-day fasting means switching between a fasting day and a normal eating day, over and over. In a year-long trial it led to about the same weight loss as ordinary daily calorie cutting, and more people gave up on it1.
What are the two versions?
Modified alternate-day fasting. On fasting days you eat a small amount, commonly around 500 calories or about a quarter of your usual needs, often as a single meal. On the days between, you eat normally. This is the version most people mean.
Zero-calorie alternate-day fasting. On fasting days you have no calories at all. If you finish dinner on Monday and next eat at breakfast on Wednesday, that is a fast of about 36 hours. Fasts longer than 24 hours carry more risk and should be done with a doctor’s supervision. For most people the modified version is the more sensible choice.
Either way, water is always allowed, and you should keep drinking it.
What do studies of alternate-day fasting show?
It works about as well as daily calorie cutting. In a trial of 100 adults with obesity that ran for one year, alternate-day fasting gave weight loss similar to cutting calories every day1. It was not better.
More people quit. In the same trial, more people dropped out of the fasting group than the daily calorie restriction group1. A plan that works on paper only helps if you can keep to it.
The fasting itself doesn’t seem to add anything. A 3-week trial in lean adults matched calories between groups. People who cut calories every day lost more body fat than people who did alternate-day fasting with the same total calories. And when people fasted on alternate days without a calorie deficit, they lost little weight2. The trial was short and the people were lean, so it may not apply to everyone, but it fits the general rule that weight change is driven mainly by the balance of calories in and out3.
Put together: alternate-day fasting is one way to eat less across the week. Its effect appears to come from the calories you skip.
Why is it hard to stick to?
- Half your days are hard days. A daily eating window asks a little every day. This asks a lot every second day, for as long as you do it.
- The calendar keeps shifting. Fasting days land on different weekdays each week, so they will sometimes fall on birthdays, work lunches and weekends.
- Hunger on fasting days can be strong, mostly in the first weeks.
- Normal days can drift. Some people eat much more than usual after a fasting day, which cancels the deficit.
If these sound like deal-breakers, the 5:2 diet uses the same idea with only two low days a week, and you choose which days.
Does exercise help?
It may. In a 12-week trial of adults with obesity, combining alternate-day fasting with endurance exercise led to more weight loss than either one alone4.
In practical terms, many people find hard sessions easier on eating days. On fasting days, walking and other light movement are usually comfortable. If you feel weak or dizzy while exercising on a fasting day, stop and eat.
Who should not try alternate-day fasting?
This is one of the most demanding fasting patterns, so the list is long. Don’t do it without a doctor’s guidance if you:
- take insulin or a sulfonylurea. People on these medicines risk low blood sugar when fasting and need a doctor to adjust their medicine first5
- take any medicine that must be taken with food
- are pregnant, trying to get pregnant or breastfeeding
- are under 18
- are underweight
- have, or have had, an eating disorder
It is also a poor first schedule. If you’re new to fasting, start with a daily window and see how you respond. More on this in who should not fast.
How to try modified alternate-day fasting
- Start with a milder pattern. A few weeks of 16:8 or 5:2 shows you how your body handles going without.
- Plan the fasting-day meal. Around 500 calories, with a good portion of protein and plenty of vegetables. Many people prefer to eat it at lunch or dinner, so they aren’t going to bed hungry.
- Eat normally on the other days. Normal portions, normal meals. Don’t feast.
- Drink water all day, plus black coffee or plain tea if you like.
- Mark the days. The weekly fasting planner lays out the pattern so you can see what’s coming.
- Review after a month. Check your weight trend, energy, sleep and mood. If fasting days are taking over your thoughts or your eating days are getting out of hand, move to something gentler.
Is it worth it?
For most people there are easier ways to get the same result. Alternate-day fasting may suit a small group who would rather have clear on and off days than moderate every day. If you’re one of them and you’re in good health, the modified version is the place to begin.
Questions people ask
What can I eat on a fasting day with alternate-day fasting?
On the modified version, most people have one small meal of around 500 calories, built around protein and vegetables. Water, black coffee and plain tea are fine through the day. On the zero-calorie version you eat nothing, which should only be done with a doctor's supervision.
Is alternate-day fasting the same as 5:2?
No. On 5:2 you have two low-calorie days a week. On alternate-day fasting every second day is a fasting day, so you have three or four of them each week, which makes it a good deal harder.
Keep reading
The 5:2 diet: two low-calorie days a week
The 5:2 diet means eating normally five days a week and about 500 to 600 calories on two. See how it works, what trials found and who should avoid it.
BlogIntermittent fasting vs calorie counting
Intermittent fasting vs calorie counting: in most trials both lead to similar weight loss. See what the studies compared and how to pick one you'll keep.
ToolWeekly Fasting Planner
Plan your fasting week, including 5:2 and alternate-day schedules. Pick your fasting days and times, then print the plan or save it as a PDF.
Sources
- Trepanowski JF, et al. (2017). Effect of Alternate-Day Fasting on Weight Loss, Weight Maintenance, and Cardioprotection Among Metabolically Healthy Obese Adults: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med.
- Templeman I, et al. (2021). A randomized controlled trial to isolate the effects of fasting and energy restriction on weight loss and metabolic health in lean adults. Sci Transl Med.
- Hall KD, Guo J (2017). Obesity Energetics: Body Weight Regulation and the Effects of Diet Composition. Gastroenterology.
- Bhutani S, et al. (2013). Alternate day fasting and endurance exercise combine to reduce body weight and favorably alter plasma lipids in obese humans. Obesity (Silver Spring).
- Grajower MM, Horne BD (2019). Clinical Management of Intermittent Fasting in Patients with Diabetes Mellitus. Nutrients.
Written with AI help and checked against the sources above. Every cited study is linked so you can read it yourself. This page is general information, not medical advice. How we write and check articles.